++ Needle Drops is now an occasional music column that a number of Neumu writers take turns writing. All columns prior to March 2004 were written by Philip Sherburne.
++ Recently ++
Tuesday, November 29, 2005 = The Stooges Unearthed (Again)
Tuesday, November 8, 2005 = Documenting Beulah And DCFC
Tuesday, November 1, 2005 = Out-Of-Control Rock 'N' Roll Is Alive And Well
Tuesday, October 25, 2005 = Just In Time For Halloween
Monday, October 3, 2005 = The Dandyesque Raunch Of Louis XI
Monday, August 15, 2005 = The Empire Blues
Tuesday, August 9, 2005 = David Howie's Sónar Diary
Monday, July 25, 2005 = Hot Sounds For Summertime
Monday, June 27, 2005 = Overcoming Writer's Block At Sónar 2005
Monday, June 4, 2005 = Cool New Sounds To Download Or Stream
++ Needle Drops Archives ++
View full list of Needle Drops articles...
Monday, November 29, 2004
++ The Electrified Journalist
By Mark Mordue
++ When I think about rock 'n' roll and my life trying to write about it, my trying to get inside rock 'n' roll through words and stories, it seems to me all I ever cared about was this thing called "the truth," or being able to celebrate, activate, animate a moment, good or bad, to put there on the page rock 'n' roll as a lived experience.
To create a riot or a love story or a sadness or even a divide the unplugged
and distant as much as the switched-on, up-close and electrical to remake
the event and the encounter: these seemed to me to be the absolute goals.
So that when someone read my "stuff" they might get as shaken up or inspired or confused as I was in relation to these people and songs and places and happenings that were moving me.
Rock 'n' roll, yeah.
Not so long ago I was invited to talk to a group of tertiary-degree music students about rock 'n' roll writing. In the course of my trying to explain myself, and the alchemy I believe in, their teacher interrupted me and said, "Isn't it true most rock journalists are just frustrated musicians?"
I'd heard that one a million times before. It's the kind of statement that pisses
you off when you're a rock journalist. It's meant to piss you off too, to put
you in your place to let you know your art form is essentially parasitic,
second-rate, a pastiche based on things you can't do. I'm sure you know the clichés: "Those
who can, do! Those who can't, write about it." "Action speaks louder than words." Blah
Without thinking too much about it I turned to the music teacher and said, "Maybe that's true. But then I think most musicians are also just frustrated musicians too."
++ Over the years I've come to see there are times when there is a struggle between musicians and writers for what you might call the "soul" of rock 'n' roll.
Of course writing can't get at the communal heat, the group energy, the sheer physical decibels of rock 'n' roll. But it can work in other ways, in another form, and be just as vital and equal to the feelings and ideas rock 'n' roll represents. It can even be better. Sure.
In some ways, it is even possible to turn up the writing, which might be one of the signposts for what rock 'n' roll writing is: the volume level of the adjectives, the unhinged energy, the wild connections and amplification of emotions. In forms normally given over to the rationalistic and the analytical in journalism and criticism rock 'n' roll writing still has a place for love and poetry, for metaphysical associations that really do believe in taking you along with the writer that much higher than you might have been before.
Maybe something was sparked during my own early efforts to write poetry, mostly
inspired by the lyrics of Marc Bolan of T-Rex. As a budding 13-year-old writer
I reamed off efforts about white lines on mirrors, lounging in jet airplanes
in swimming pools full of lions and naked women. I didn't really know what it
was all about, but it sounded fantastic, and the influence of a drug-indulged,
globe-hopping hippie-mystic English pop star definitely had its positive side.
I dreamt. Ridiculously, wildly. But I dreamt.
When I was a teenager in the '70s, magazines like RAM (Rock Australia Magazine) and the NME (New Musical Express) from England further articulated the sounds and activities, the style and language of a culture completely alternative, or beyond where I was as a suburban boy in Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia.
As much as through the sounds, and of course the lyrics that I studied so carefully, I fell deeper into music because of these magazines and the people who wrote for them. At the NME it was the writings of Paul Morley in particular who first awakened me to the fact a magazine article could have all the grace and intelligence of a fine short story or theatre piece.
In Australia, where I live, Andrew McMillan's stories in RAM got me interested in Tom Waits and Hunter S. Thompson and Jack Kerouac, which dovetailed, I would discover, with Bob Dylan's links with the Allen Ginsberg and the whole Beat scene, as well as French poets like Arthur Rimbaud, who, I saw, inspired Van Morrison as well as Dylan, and even someone as punk as Patti Smith.
Much later I realized there was an argument that the 19th-century Rimbaud was the first true punk, not '60s American garage bands, not singers like Richard Hell, not Johnny Rotten at all.
By this stage of my teens I was already heavily into Joseph Heller's Catch
22 and Something Happened; into the twists and shouts of Hamlet (surely
Shakespeare's most rock 'n' roll play), as well as the comic-book existentialism
of the Marvel super heroes; into actors like Al Pacino in Dog Day Afternoon and Serpico, and
books like Catcher in the Rye (which seemed to inspire all kinds of assassins,
including Mark Chapman, the killer of John Lennon), as well as records like On
the Beach and Tonight's the Night , in which Neil Young sang about
bad heroin, Charles Manson and, funnily enough, how much rock critics pissed
him off ("Walk On"); into Albert Camus (who later inspired The Cure to write "Killing
An Arab"), sci-fi books, UFO cover-up conspiracy theories, vampire novels, Elvis
Presley movies on midday TV, the cinematic obsession with Americana in most of
Bernie Taupin's lyrics for prime-time Elton John; into David Bowie and how alien
and drug-fucked he seemed when they screened the "Cracked Actor" doco on ABC
(when he uttered the words "there's a fly in my milk" as he sat staring into
a carton, clearly out of it, in the back of a limousine, he may as well been
speaking some revolutionary form of Sanskrit to me) and how weirdly he danced
Years" on "Soul Train."
It all made sense to me; it all felt connected.
++ You could say by the time punk arrived, and what was later called "New Wave," I was ripe for further development. Punk's DIY spirit and the intellectual, arty pretensions of the New Wave along with the rock magazines I was reading fed a sense that I could actually get involved.
In magazine interviews this somewhat disparate movement's main stars, figures like Johnny Rotten (Sex Pistols), Paul Weller (The Jam), Joe Strummer (The Clash) and Howard Devoto (The Buzzcocks) in the UK, and Chris Bailey (The Saints), Nick Cave (The Birthday Party) and Sean Kelly (Models) here, spoke of influences that opened up a cultural history I'd never known of, often dark and certainly obscure. The Velvet Underground, the MC5 and The New York Dolls, Marxist politics, German expressionism film and art, William Faulkner, W.B. Yeats, Celine, reggae and French cultural theory all came tumbling through the hole they punched in my life.
Maybe there was also something in the fundamental ethos that this music wasn't entirely above or beyond me in the brute democracies of punk, and the art-house exoticism and experimentation, even the uncomfortable superiority of New Wave that appealed to me as an adolescent boy. Whatever the answer to that mystery, I was launched as a writer.
I think there is a vaguely religious quality to all this, that writing about
music and writing inspired by music leads to songs of innocence and experience
on the page as much as between the ears. It's a devotional act, a real love thing,
which is why it can be an angry and hateful and messy thing too. I often think
the best rock 'n' roll magazines and writers have a reach-for-the-stars touch
of anarchy about them, a sense of risk that inevitably involves failure as much
as moments of white-light wonder. It depresses me to look at most rock 'n' roll
magazines today by comparison: the Pepsi Cola cool they promote; the tame and
stylized rebellion; the often dull, hypey and self-satisfied writing. The awful
truth in today's over-designed media world is that if Hunter S. Thompson or Lester
Bangs turned up today at the doors of Rolling Stone writing at their peak
their powers, they'd be turned away because they did not fit the format.
Sorry guys, too passionate, too wild, too weird. I hope the zine scene and the
Internet are the places where that honesty and talent can find a better voice.
An American rock critic like Lester Bangs understood the need for this energy, in columns and interviews and reviews, that rampaged through his relationship with rock 'n' roll and its music stars. Perhaps better than anyone, Bangs at his best (and Bangs was not always at his best) could evoke the actual feelings of listening to music, the way you heard it, in words. Alternatively, an English writer as fine as Nick Kent exuded a more elegant discipline in stories largely fascinated with the self-destructive and exiling impulses that would also exert their own pull upon him. Bangs would eventually die of his own excessive lifestyle and later be immortalized in "Almost Famous" as the mentor to the young lead character ("People like us aren't cool") while Nick Kent would find himself, for a brief moment, the singer of an unknown group called the Sex Pistols before Johnny Rotten got the job and he was unceremoniously booted out. That a sadness, a hurt, plagues both Bangs and Kent who seems to have faded off the scene for all their talent does not detract from just how good they are as writers. Nor does the fact that they tried to sing, to play. They just wanted to live it all.
++ Funnily enough a lot of the contemporary rock 'n' roll scene seems to be looking towards the literary world to enliven it. At events in London, performance poets like John Cooper Clarke and Linton Kwesi Johnson, both of whom emerged in the wake of punk and dub, have ranked alongside Will Self, Sadie Smith and Jarvis Cocker of Pulp in evenings of musical and literary dialogue in the past few years. Poetry, it seems, is becoming hip, cool. Apart from the longtime notable work of the Nuyorican Café scene in the U.S.A., there is now also the annual 215 Festival in Philadelphia, organized by Dave Eggers and his team from the McSweeney's Web site, featuring the likes of Zadie Smith, Jeffrey Eugenides and Jonathan Ames alongside groups like They Might Be Giants.
This bridge-building between writers and musicians is hardly new. It's how Patti
Smith emerged as an artist. It's what gave Dylan so much artistic credibility.
But certainly since the advent of rock 'n' roll one can see an ongoing and developing
body of work that details something larger, which we might call the cultural
history of our rock 'n' roll lives, from On the Road to Fear and Loathing
in Las Vegas to One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Less Than Zero, The
Ice Storm, Twelve, The Fight Club, He Died With a Felafel
In His Hand… the list, like the beat, goes on!
So when it finally comes down to it, I sincerely believe French poetry and the Beats are just as important to modern rock 'n' roll as the blues and Woody Guthrie. The same way we couldn't have had the outburst of New Journalism in the 1960s and the radical subjectivity of so much literary non-fiction today without rock 'n' roll opening people's minds alongside it.
Artists like Brett Whiteley and Tracey Emin, poets like Allen Ginsberg and Robert Adamson, rock journalists like Lester Bangs and Nick Kent, are just as much a part of rock 'n' roll as Lou Reed or the Rolling Stones or even Eminem. That's the truly wild and mutable thing about rock 'n' roll it's an energy that can't be held and chained up or robbed of its magic and dissent. It begs in the end for trouble and divinity and sex and whatever ruptures we can celebrate it with. It's escaped into our entire culture, our dreams, our unconscious life, and a musician or even a crap magazine doesn't own it, any more than a couple speeding out of town to the sounds of You Am I, M Ward and Kings of Leon on the radio.
Mark Mordue is the author of Dastgah: Diary of a Headtrip, published in the U.S.A. through Hawthorne Books in November, 2004.